Skip to main content

Composition and Feelings

lonetree(Sony A55)

Can composition in photography be learnt? In a cliché way of a reply, yes and no, depending on how you look at composition.

It is not really opinionated to say that no photographer hasn’t learned about compositional techniques at some point of time by reading guidebooks, studying works of others or soliciting advices from old hands. I for one have tried all of these. Just as any techniques, compositional skills can be learnt.

However, it is clear as one travels further in photography that compositional contemplation isn’t just about implementing standardised codes. In fact, I am starting to query the conventional wisdom of treating compositional principles as a paradigm standing on its own. It is in this sense that I think composition cannot be learnt.

Take today’s shot for example.

At the sight of this spot the question immediately jumped to my mind, in a split of a second, was how to frame a nature shot. Probably intuitive to every adept photographer, the typical rule and sure-fire way is none other than enclosing the centre of interest with the usable elements of landscape around. But chances are that no landscape element is available around and maybe they are changing too fast for that purpose as in the case of this shot.

This scene captured my attention as the 4-wheel drive was whishing across the desert to the next sand dunes in Dubai. Seeing through the viewfinder, I fixed my eye on it and decisively snapped the shot when the elements within the frame fell into place. It should be pointed out that the driver hadn’t slowed down the car for my sake which was going in like 110 km/h (roughly 68 mph). So, no chance to compose in a proper sense really. Fact is, however, I did not fumble for any second there and then with the composition as a matter of its own. The composition, together with the exposure combo, simply serves to reflect my state of mind at that decisive moment.

Now, to decipher the shot’s composition in a technical way, I can say that putting the lone tree on the left bestows the image with a continuous view as this conforms to our habit of reading (maybe except for Arab readers whose language is read from right to left); checked. The green bit of the tree is roughly on the golden intersection; checked. The one third distribution between the land and the sky is a commonly taught compositional technique; checked. Nothing to engage the viewers on the left portion of the shot – not so good. I could also say that I might have probably viewed the scene in geometric forms. So on and so forth.

But I would rather see the shot as a whole in terms of how it reflected my state of mind. It was taken on my last day of the Dubai trip when my frustration over the various hacked online accounts and the tiredness under the hellish heat were subsiding. It was meant to be a chance to stay away from the hectic work at home but, paradoxically, the prospect of going home somehow gave me a peace of mind (which street photographer won’t with no mobile communication under a weather too hot for street photography). After all, the vista outside of the car windows was captivating. I saw the tree braving the heat on the dry desert. It was a sign of hope which connected to my feelings. Looking through the viewfinder, I snapped the shot when the elements combined to best reflect such feelings of mine. I did not compose the shot to fall in line with the technical rules or to amaze the viewers in the first place.

In a nutshell, what is important is not whether compositional technique can be learnt. To me, composition is only as good as the technical rules can get if without first fermenting one’s feelings towards a scene. The rules of composition in photography can and should be learnt as a technique to build a stepping stone from which one should move on to look at the compositional device not for its own sake but, together with other photographic devices, for use to reflect one’s feelings which should be there in the first place.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

GXR: External Flash and Viewfinder

We are nearly the end of the GXR field report series.  I wish to talk about the external options for the GXR, namely, the flashgun and the viewfinder.The external flash named, well, GF-1 can do TTL flash on Ricoh cameras with the flash interface as illustrated below, which Ricoh called Type R.  It can also be used on  other Ricoh cameras which have no TTL-flash capability like the GX200.When the TTL-A LED is on after the flash has been mounted and turned on, it is ready to do TTL flash.A few presses on the lower rectangular power level select button will light up the last two LEDs on the far right, activating the manual flash output via adjustment on the GXR.The flashgun can turn upwards up to 90°for doing bounce flash but not sideways.  It can double as a wireless slave flash.  For that matter, it comes with a stand.  I have read through the instruction manual but can't find the clue as to whether in slave mode it will automatically distribute the flash output between the main/ t…

Property Hegemony

(Ricoh GX200)

Property Hegemony is a hot issue in the city.  It refers to the near or actual cartel comprising the local tycoons in the property market.  A worthy read on the topic is a book titled Land and the Ruling Class in Hong Kong by Alice Poon, a former assistant to a local property tycoon, who wrote it after she migrated to Canada. The book won the Canadian Book Review Annual a few years ago. 
Property hegemony is not an illusionary thing.  Alice has given her readers lots of data to justify the debate.  For example, in 2010, the six richest local clans who are all property developers controlled 14.7% of the Hong Kong stock market value.  This gives a glimpse into the result of the fact that while from 1991 to 1994, 70% of Hong Kong’s private property were built by seven property developers, 55% out of this amount was developed by four of the seven developers.  Today, most major property sites are owned by the biggest three to four among them.
The adverse impacts are very stron…

GXR M-mount Field Test: Voigtländer Nokton 35mm F1.2 ASPH II Lens

The M module may better be described as a far-flung cousin to rather than an immediate member of the GXR family. When look closer, you may see that the whole point of the M module is not about a new GXR-system module – fact is, the concept of lens-sensor combination is completely forsaken here. It is more about taking advantage of the wide choice of high quality M mount lenses.

In this post, we will look at the lens on loan to us: the Voigtländer Nokton 35mm F1.2 ASPH II.


Although Leica M-mount lenses are the best choice for optical performance, they are not just everyone’s option pricewise. With a lower price tag and great optical performance, Voigtländer lenses are sensible substitutes. Hong Kong’s sole dealer of Ricoh cameras, Laikok, is also the distributor of Voigtländer lenses (manufactured by Cosina of Japan) in Hong Kong. For information about the Voigtländer lenses available from Laikok, check this out.  You may also check out Cosina’s Voigtländer webpage.


With the Voigtländer …