Skip to main content

GF2 Field Test: Questioning the Touch Screen

panasonicgf2 A marked difference compared to the GF1, the touch screen functionality is supposedly the biggest draw of the GF2. Does this do any good to the handling and shooting in reality? Without boring you with the details of the on-screen menus which you can surely find elsewhere or in the operating instructions, let's explore the answers.

The i-Phone and the lookalike gadgets have swept the world with the increasingly popular touch-screen activation. This function works every fine on cell phones and computing pads. But the story is a bit different in the case of a camera.

The Bad

With, say, a cell phone, the user can unlock the screen which is important to prevent accidental touching of the screen. However, there is no way to lock and unlock the screen of the GF2. After it is turned on and before it goes into sleep mode, the screen can be touched with or without intent. Users who have the habit of keeping the camera on will find themselves touching the screen to activate a function by chance. This happened for 90% of the time when we used the camera. This does inconvenience the user.

SAM_2637s In our case, it was the focus area selection which we mostly activated accidentally.  Although the selected focus didn't require lots of tabbing to be remedied, the touch-activation function of the focus area selection – unlike the touch-screen shutter, guide, scroll, de-focus and quick menu – cannot be turned off. That is to day, there is no way to avoid the possibility of activating it accidentally.

 

The Good

image (Apart from tracking the subject and releasing the shutter, touching the screen can also set the position of the AF area – great for doing portraits)

Call it every cloud has a silver lining or the other side of the coin, the touch screen operation certainly has its merits. It is very when it comes to doing portraits. A touch on the selected area will lock the focus and, if the touch-screen shutter is on, take the picture. You will never need to mess around the button to select the desired focus area as in other cameras.

image (Viewing photos, especially playing back videos, has never been easier like with the GF2's touch screen functionality)

The touch screen is put to the best use when viewing photos. It works like any smart phones' in viewing photos. A swap of the figure across the screen brings you to another photo or back to the previous one. Pointing the figure on the screen at a specific area of the image will enlarge it. Deleting multiple images has never been easier – simply touch to select the shots to be deleted and then the on-screen OK button.

The screen responses quickly to every touch even though not as smoothly as the remarkable iPhone4' s retina screen. We have no complaint about the responsiveness of the screen.

As a side note, the screen at 460,000 dots, which is not stunning at today's standards, has a good viewing angle of,  according to our observation, nearly 270 degree. The brightness can be set to automatically enhance under bright environmental light. Just as any other new cameras in this class, GF2's screen has comparable visibility (i.e. barely visible) when shooting under bright sunlight. Surely, for that matter, Samsung's AMOLED screen is still unrivalled.

A Blessing to Photographers?

touch_screen_operation The touch-screen is as good as it gets. To old-hand photographers, the touch screen thingy is a gimmick which is not indispensable, much less than the forfeited dial and lever (situated under the dial) on the GF1. To the newer i-generation, maybe it works more intuitively. Our verdict is that if the touch-screen operation doesn't prevent the diving into menus, which it doesn't in the case of GF2, the implementation is not desirable. The tiny GF2 body makes accidental touching of the screen an issue.

SAM_2636s There is one more vexation about the touch screen. While the cluster of the on-screen photographic information can be turned off, the Disp(lay) icon doesn't go off (and also the touch-screen shutter activation and Q.Menu icons if the physical Q.Menu button is set to function as a Fn button) unless the shutter release is half passed. The relatively sizeable icons effectively prevent the photographer to check out the elements on the screen at where these icons are situated. This can be forgiven on a point-and-shoot camera. But the GF-2 is no point-and-shooter. And even on a point-and-shooter, the on-screen information can usually be completely turned off .

panasonicgf1 In short, the touch-screen functionality is a mixed blessing to users of the GF2. At best, it is more useful for doing tweaking and viewing photos but can be done without for shooting. As for us, the conventional dials and lever on the GF1 are preferable.

(to be continued)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Real Hero

(Grip On Reality: This photo was taken on my way to work.  I was walking past trucks parking on a cul-de-sac when the ropes caught my attention.  The light was right, the colour was right and the criss-crossing pattern was perfect and I held up my GX200.  People passing by checked me out and wondered what could be made out of such a boring scene.  To me, the fun in photography is that the photographer makes something interesting out of what is not obvious to most at the scene.  The ropes tied in knots somehow reminded people I know who are in the grip of the recession) You must have also known a friend or two, or even yourself, being baffled by the spiral downturn of the economy.   Bank went bankrupt and the rich was faced with a shrinking wealth.  A friend of mine has just had his salary cut by over 10% and some of his colleagues started to be shed. But, wait. Was this done really for the sake of continuing the business? Or is there a factor or greed in it?  I wonder whether the

New Low Prices

The window shopping some hours ago has almost provoked my AgIDS illness.  Just in case you’re in Hong Kong or are coming here, and have the money to burn (All in HK$/ body only): GX200 = $3,280 GRD2 = $3,380 LX3 = $3,180 G10 = $3,280 Prices are available form a gear shop on the 1st floor of the Mongkok Computer Centre.   Besides these new low prices, I found that Wing Shing Photo (55-57Sai Yeung Choi St., MK Tel: 2396 6886/ 91-95 Fa Yuen St., MK  Tel: 2396 6885) is offering a Sony A700 + Carl Zeiss Lens package for HK$9,980 (hopefully, a bargain will make it some hundreds cheaper).

Eye Contact

(Leica D-lux 5) The digital era may make it easier to end up with fave shots. Even lousy photos may be turned likable after a few clicks in the post-processing workflow. But if digital advancement or amendments have any bearing on the cultivation of personal style, no photographers will need to discover his or her own photographer’s eye. Undoutedly, this is out of the question. Only with a trained photographer’s eye can we give a thinking gaze and capture an eternal moment, in our unique style. Style is the soul of a great photo. A few posts have been written in GXG to touch on the topic of photographer’s eye. Instead of finding an answer, which would require academic discussions, the posts are intended to give my general reflections and spark interests in moving towards further exploration of the topic.  The posts can be viewed after the links: 1) Photographer's Eye: Storytelling 2) Photographer's Eye: Little Show of Observing 3) Photographer's Eye: Sight-Worthy 4